Why can aluminium not be welded like steel?
Aluminium conducts heat around three times as well as steel, expands twice as much and melts at just 660 °C. Its oxide skin, by contrast, melts only at around 2,050 °C, and the molten metal absorbs hydrogen, which forms pores during solidification. Anyone who welds aluminium with habits from steel fabrication gets lack of fusion, distortion, oxide inclusions and porosity.
The use of aluminium and its alloys has been growing for years, above all in vehicle, rail vehicle and shipbuilding. Lightweight construction saves energy in operation. That is why fabricators are switching from steel to aluminium, or new companies start with aluminium straight away.
The processes and terms often differ only slightly from steel: MIG instead of MAG, TIG as usual, and the equipment looks similar. That is exactly what tempts people to treat aluminium like steel. In fact, many properties behave in almost opposite ways. Knowing them avoids costly rework, scrap and delays. This page gives an overview; the articles at the end go into the individual topics in depth.
Which properties distinguish aluminium from steel?
Aluminium is around three times lighter and three times less stiff than iron, conducts heat three times and electricity about four times as well, expands twice as much and melts at less than half the temperature. What matters for welding is heat conduction, expansion, the oxide layer and the solubility of hydrogen.
| Property | Unit | Aluminium (Al) | Iron (Fe) | Ratio Al : Fe |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atomic weight | g/mol | 26.98 | 55.84 | ≈ 1 : 2 |
| Crystal lattice | – | face-centred cubic | body-centred cubic | – |
| Density | g/cm³ | 2.70 | 7.87 | ≈ 1 : 3 |
| Young's modulus | GPa | 67 | 210 | ≈ 1 : 3 |
| Coefficient of thermal expansion | 10⁻⁶/K | 24 | 12 | ≈ 2 : 1 |
| Yield strength Rp0.2 | MPa | ≈ 10 | ≈ 100 | ≈ 1 : 10 |
| Tensile strength Rm | MPa | ≈ 50 | ≈ 200 | ≈ 1 : 4 |
| Specific heat | J/(kg·K) | ≈ 890 | ≈ 460 | ≈ 2 : 1 |
| Heat of fusion | J/g | ≈ 390 | ≈ 272 | ≈ 1.5 : 1 |
| Melting point | °C (K) | 660 (933) | 1,538 (1,811) | ≈ 1 : 2 |
| Thermal conductivity | W/(m·K) | 235 | 75 | ≈ 3 : 1 |
| Electrical conductivity | MS/m | 38 | ≈ 10 | ≈ 4 : 1 |
| Oxides | – | Al₂O₃ | FeO / Fe₂O₃ / Fe₃O₄ | – |
| Melting point of the oxides | °C | 2,050 | 1,400 / 1,455 / 1,600 | for Fe similar to the metal, for Al around three times as high |
| Density of the oxides | g/cm³ | 3.89 | 5.7 / 5.2 / ≈ 5.0 | Fe oxides lighter than steel, Al oxide heavier than aluminium |
Guide values for the pure metals at room temperature. Alloys differ, especially in strength and conductivity. Density, Young's modulus and strength matter mainly for design; for welding, the following differences count.
What does the high thermal conductivity do in welding?
Aluminium conducts heat away from the weld zone very quickly. At the start of the weld the component is still cold, and lack of fusion is a risk. As the weld progresses, the heat runs ahead of the arc, the component gets hotter and hotter and the weld pool larger. With different wall thicknesses, the thick part draws the heat away while the thin part overheats.
This leads to three rules for practice:
- Weld start: start with increased power (hot start) or preheat thick sections, see Preheating and interpass temperature.
- Along the weld and at the end: adjust current or travel speed to the increasing heat and fill the end crater, see Weld start and end crater.
- Thin to thick: as a rule of thumb from practice, the wall thickness ratio should not exceed 1:3. Beyond that, the current setting does not help, only the design does: taper transitions, machine steps or bevels and direct the heat onto the thick part.
The heat also reaches the clamping fixtures. They must be built sturdily enough not to distort and may need cooling in series production. How much energy goes into the weld is shown by the heat input calculator.
Video (in German): why the thick part draws the heat away and how the design helps.
Why does aluminium distort more, and does rigid clamping help?
Aluminium expands twice as much as steel when heated and shrinks correspondingly on cooling. Unrestrained components therefore distort more. If a rigid fixture blocks the shrinkage, residual stresses and hot cracks result. The solution lies in between: position rather than lock in.
The rule from our video: completely free means distortion, completely rigid means cracking. With aluminium, the right point lies closer to the flexible side than with steel. Proven measures:
- fix only where necessary for position and dimensions, and use flexible rather than rigid clamping elements,
- make tack welds large enough that they do not crack during welding,
- a welding sequence that distributes the heat, such as backstep or skip welding,
- low-heat processes such as pulsed MIG or modern short-arc processes.
With aluminium, distortion must therefore be planned for in design and fixture construction. Against hot cracks, the right filler metal also helps, see the selection table below.
Video (in German): what happens to the shrinkage and what a fixture looks like that positions rather than locks in.
Why is arc ignition more difficult with aluminium?
Aluminium conducts electricity about four times as well as iron, and wire and workpiece are covered with an insulating oxide layer. On ignition, there is therefore none of the electrical resistance that quickly heats the free wire end with steel. The results are unreliable ignition, spatter and lack of fusion at the weld start.
The remedy is a correctly set ignition phase on the power source, even wire feed and a clean wire end. More under Arc ignition.
Why is the oxide layer the real problem?
In air, aluminium immediately forms a thin layer of aluminium oxide (Al₂O₃). It melts only at around 2,050 °C, far above the metal at 660 °C, and at 3.9 g/cm³ it is heavier than molten aluminium. Oxide residues therefore do not float to the top as with steel, but sink and remain in the weld as inclusions or lack of fusion.
With steel, the oxides are lighter than the metal and melt at a similar temperature; they rise as slag. With aluminium, the oxide layer must be dealt with before and during welding:
- Before welding degrease and remove the oxide layer mechanically, shortly beforehand, because it grows back immediately. Details under Surface preparation before welding. For joint preparation and opening roots, milling instead of grinding is a clean alternative.
- During welding the arc breaks up the oxide skin when the electrode is positive: in MIG welding with direct current on the positive pole, in TIG welding with alternating current.
The outer part of the oxide layer is porous and binds moisture. This makes it a source of hydrogen and porosity as well. More under Oxide layer.
Where does porosity in aluminium welds come from?
Liquid aluminium dissolves around twenty times more hydrogen than solid aluminium. On solidification the hydrogen is released abruptly, and whatever can no longer escape remains as a pore in the weld. The main sources are moisture in the oxide layer, condensation, grease and dirt on workpiece and wire, and moisture in the shielding gas.
- Store workpieces and wire dry and do not bring them cold into a warm, humid workshop. Whether condensation forms is shown by the dew point calculator; background under Condensation.
- Clean surfaces shortly before welding and keep opened wire spools protected.
- Keep gas hoses and torch leak-tight, because moist shielding gas carries hydrogen straight into the arc.
The physics behind it is explained in Solubility of hydrogen.
Which filler metal suits which aluminium alloy?
The basic rule: weld pure aluminium with pure aluminium filler, aluminium-magnesium alloys with AlMg fillers and casting alloys with AlSi fillers. For AlMgSi alloys (6000 series) the requirement decides: AlMg for strength and colour match after anodising, AlSi for low cracking tendency. For every combination of two base metals, the material selector gives a recommendation.
| Base metal | Examples | MIGAL.CO filler metal |
|---|---|---|
| Pure aluminium | EN AW-1050A, 1070A, 1350 | MA-1450 (Al99,5Ti), MA-1070 (Al99,7); if prone to cracking MA-4043 |
| AlMn | EN AW-3003, 3103 | MA-4043 (AlSi5) |
| AlMg below 1 % | EN AW-5005 | MA-4043 (AlSi5) |
| AlMg around 3 % | EN AW-5754, 5052, 5454 | MA-5754 (AlMg3), MA-5356 (AlMg5Cr); above 65 °C service temperature Mg content around 3 %, e.g. MA-5754 or MA-5554 |
| AlMg around 5 % | EN AW-5083, 5086, 5383 | MA-5183 (AlMg4,5Mn0,7), MA-5087 (AlMg4,5MnZr) for thick plates and stiff structures, MA-5556A for highest strength |
| AlMgSi | EN AW-6060, 6063, 6005A, 6061, 6082 | strength and corrosion: MA-5183, MA-5356; low cracking tendency: MA-4043, MA-4047; matching: MA-6063 |
| AlZnMg | EN AW-7020 | MA-5183, MA-5087, MA-5556A |
| AlCu | EN AW-2219 | only conditionally weldable; MA-2319 (AlCu6MnZrTi), against hot cracks MA-4043 |
| Cast AlSi(Mg) | EN AC-42100, 43000, 44200 | MA-4018 (AlSi7Mg), MA-4046 (AlSi10Mg), MA-4047 (AlSi12), MA-4043 |
| Cast AlSiCu | EN AC-46000 | MA-4043, MA-4047 |
Recommendations for identical base metals, as stored in the material selector. AlSi fillers turn dark grey when anodised, the more so the more silicon they contain.
For dissimilar joints and weighting by strength, corrosion or weldability: Material selection aluminium alloys. All wires and rods with data sheet, standard designation and approvals: Aluminium welding wire.
Why is wire feeding critical with aluminium?
Aluminium wire is soft and not very stiff: its strength is far below that of steel wire, its Young's modulus one third. In the torch cable assembly it buckles more easily, friction slows it down and causes abrasion. If the feed fluctuates, the arc fluctuates, with porosity, lack of fusion and burn-backs as a result.
- Keep feeding distances short, use plastic liners and rolls with a U-groove; no steel spirals or V-groove rolls from steel equipment.
- For long distances from the drum to the robot, use wire conduits with rollers such as Rolliner 3G or Rolliner NG. Examples under Long-distance wire feeding for aluminium.
- Look for consistent wire quality: tight diameter tolerance, clean surface and even layer winding. MIGAL.CO shaves its aluminium wires and then forms the surface again under defined conditions, see Oxide layer.
In detail under Wire feeding.
Frequently asked questions
Can aluminium be welded with the same MIG machine as steel?
Basically yes, if the power source has an aluminium program, preferably pulsed, and the wire feed is converted: plastic liner instead of steel spiral, rolls with a U-groove, a suitable contact tip and the shortest possible torch cable assembly or a push-pull torch. With unchanged steel equipment, feeding problems are the rule.
Does aluminium have to be preheated before welding?
Not as a rule. Preheating helps with thick sections against lack of fusion at the weld start and drives off moisture. With age-hardenable alloys such as the 6000 and 7000 series, temperature and duration must be limited, otherwise the heat-affected zone loses strength. Guidance under Preheating and interpass temperature.
Which shielding gas is needed for aluminium?
Argon (I1), helium (I2) or argon-helium mixtures (I3). Helium increases heat input and penetration and helps with thick plates and against lack of fusion. Active gases as used for MAG welding of steel are not suitable for aluminium.
Why does the weld turn dark after anodising?
AlSi fillers oxidise during anodising and turn dark grey, the more so the more silicon they contain. If the weld is to be as inconspicuous as possible after anodising, AlMg fillers matching the base metal are the better choice. More under Anodising.
Further reading: articles on welding aluminium
The series follows the order of fabrication, from surface preparation to the finished weld. For an overview, see Welding aluminium: what is different from steel.
About the author
Robert Lahnsteiner, Ing., is an International Welding Engineer (IWE) and managing director of MIGAL.CO GmbH. After training in telecommunications and electronics at HTL Braunau, he spent eighteen years in welding technology at Fronius from 1983. Since 2001 he has run MIGAL.CO, the aluminium welding wire manufacturer in Landau an der Isar, together with Martin Erl. His focus is aluminium filler metals, wire manufacturing and wire feeding, and the monitoring of welding processes. Within DVS, the German Welding Society, he has served for around 30 years on technical committee FA03 “Arc welding” and chairs working group 2.4.4 “MIG welding of aluminium”.